A Comparison of Performance Measures for Online Algorithms.

Joan Boyar, Sandy Irani, and Kim S. Larsen.
In 11th International Algorithms and Data Structures Symposium (WADS), volume 5664 of Lecture Notes in Computer Science, pages 119-130. Springer, 2009.

This paper provides a systematic study of several proposed measures for online algorithms in the context of a specific problem, namely, the two server problem on three colinear points. Even though the problem is simple, it encapsulates a core challenge in online algorithms which is to balance greediness and adaptability. We examine Competitive Analysis, the Max/Max Ratio, the Random Order Ratio, Bijective Analysis and Relative Worst Order Analysis, and determine how these measures compare the Greedy Algorithm and Lazy Double Coverage, commonly studied algorithms in the context of server problems. We find that by the Max/Max Ratio and Bijective Analysis, Greedy is the better algorithm. Under the other measures, Lazy Double Coverage is better, though Relative Worst Order Analysis indicates that Greedy is sometimes better. Our results also provide the first proof of optimality of an algorithm under Relative Worst Order Analysis.

---

publication

Link to the publication at the publisher's site - subscription may be required.
Text required by the publisher (if any): The final publication is available at link.springer.com.

full version

Link to the journal version containing all the material and proofs, some of which are usually omitted in the conference version due to space constraints.

open access (153 KB)

The same as the publisher's version, when the publisher permits. Otherwise, the author's last version before the publisher's copyright; this is often exactly the same, but sometimes fonts, page numbers, figure numbers, etc. are different. It may also be a full version. However, it is safe to read this version, and at the same time cite the official version, as long as references to concrete locations, numbered theorems, etc. inside the article are avoided.

other publications

Other publications by the author.